2025 Pizza Guide

An Italian and American restaurant with a huge recreation room including pool tables. 

Specializing in exquisite and refreshing island cuisine in a classy yet casual tropical ambience, Barefoot Bernie's Tropical Grill & Bar has become a true destination on the Outer Banks restaurant circuit. The bright and welcoming family environment is filled with vintage travel posters and tropical decorations, giving diners the sensation of being on a tropical island. Colorful walls and unique light fixtures create the perfect ambience for a tasty meal and a tropical cocktail. The owner having grown up on the Outer Banks has traveled the tropics to taste and learn the exquisite flavors these destinations have to offer. Now he is back to bring you the best dishes from the world best beaches.  

Head to Benny Tesoro's in Nags Head. Golden brown crust with a white creamy mozz, lightly crisped with bubbles.  Come as hungry as the pirates, grab a beer next door at the Lost Colony Brewery, and wreck yourself on our 28" pizzas.

Colington Pizza offers unique, gourmet pizzas as well as sandwiches and salads. Kids and grown ups all love pizza, so let Colington Pizza serve your entire family. 

Serving fresh pizza for more than two decades!

Dare Devil’s Pizzeria is the perfect beach town pizzeria, where you can enjoy good food and a casual atmosphere with a menu that will please anyone in your group. Whether you’re in the mood for pizza, or you prefer a salad, sandwich or appetizers, Dare Devils is sure to please.Family-owned and operated since 1987, Dare Devil’s has served residents and visitors of the Outer Banks for more than 30 years.Dare Devil’s fresh pizza pies have a crisp, chewy crust, are topped with a delicious tomato sauce and loaded with cheese and other toppings of your choice. Feta cheese lovers will love Dare Devils’ Greek salad and famous Crazy Greek pizza! Other specialty pizzas include Garden Pesto, North Shore (pineapple and ham), BBQ Chicken and Three Amigos (a taco-salad style pizza). If you’re hunger needs a pizza that packs more of a punch, try one of Dare Devil’s massively stuffed strombolis, which you can order in a small or large size.Enjoy a meal and a drink at the bar, or sit family style in the large dining room. The surf-decor dining room is great for hosting large groups and is kid friendly. Seasonal outdoor seating is available. If you’re looking to grab a pizza on the go, Dare Devil’s offers fast take out service. Call ahead or walk-in and order at the bar. The restaurant’s close proximity to the beach makes it a perfect stop for take out during a day of sun, surf and sand.

Pizza, sandwiches and snacks are available for carry out or delivery at this familiar favorite. Domino’s Pizza is where you’ll satisfy a craving for hot, delicious, cheesy pizza and subs with all your favorite toppings. Great pizza at great prices.With 9,000 stores worldwide, you’re certainly familiar with Domino's Pizza. What you might not know is that ordering from Domino’s is a breeze online. You could call to place an order, but why not go high-tech and place your order via an app on your cell phone. There are always new specials and coupons available on the Domino’s Pizza website and app, which is why it’s a great idea to order online instead of calling. However you place your order, you’ll quickly have dinner complete, maybe even breakfast the next morning too!Domino’s Pizza always pleases a crowd.

Duck Pizza Company’s menu features a huge selection of creative pizza combinations with 24 varieties to choose from. They also offer a variety of ice cold beer. Eat in, take out or take advantage of free delivery from Pine Island to Southern Shores. It’s open for lunch and dinner daily in season.

WELCOME TO OBX’S HOTTEST GATHERING SPOT—a celebration of craft, comfort, community, & conversation. LOCATED IN THE NEWLY RESTORED HOTEL MANTEO, we’re serving up stone-oven pizzas & hearth-fired skillets, along with Weeping Radish craft beers, killer cocktails, & (coming soon) a rollicking beer garden. So come & EAT & DRINK WITH US. LIVE & LAUGH WITH US. At Firetender, every night is a party. And every night is filled with friends …  

Delicious sauce and crust make for delicious pizza! 

Casual Italian eatery with delicious choices. 

Bakery, breakfast and pizza dinners at a Hateras Island mainstay. 

Whether you are on the hunt for a filling and fresh breakfast or a wholly unique and inspired lunch, Helios' Hideaway can satisfy the largest of appetites on Ocracoke Island. Distinctive for its tempting range of Greek fare that ranges from salads to hefty pizzas, this relatively new addition to the Ocracoke dining scene steals the show with its global flavors that can’t be found anywhere else on the southern Outer Banks.

A Sicilian-style restaurant with a cozy ambiance. 

Lucky 12 Tavern, located at Milepost 12 Beach Road has everything a great restaurant and bar should have: great food, great beverages, tons of personality and lots of TV's.  Lucky 12 prides itself on serving the freshest North Carolina Seafood and Locally Sourced Produce.  Other dining options include Hand Pattied Burgers, Wings, Cheese steaks and Creative Salads along with a Kids Menu and New York Style Pizza.  This delicious Pizza is served till 2 am Nightly.  Lucky 12 also features 20 Beers on Draft and over 80 Craft beers by the bottle or can.  They also have and extensive Martini menu and a nice Wine Selection.  For sports fans, they offer 20 TV's showcasing the MLB package, NHL Package, NFL Sunday Ticket along with tons of College Sports Packages.  For you late night fans the bar stays open till 2 AM nightly and has a pool table, Golden Tee Golf and pinball machines.  Come see why this Tavern has been a popular destination for Tourists and Locals since 2006.

Enjoy a crowd-pleasing meal that everyone can dive into with a quick stop at this Nags Head *take out only* eatery that has plenty of traditional and specialty pies to suit all tastes. Madisons Pizza has a lengthy menu that is chock full of delicious items, ensuring that every hungry visitor can find something to easily enjoy with every visit.

If you are looking for authentic cuisine and the area’s best New York style stone oven pizza made from scratch, you will love Max’s Italian Restaurant.  Max’s  is conveniently located in the Dare Centre MP 6 3/4 in Kill Devil Hills and owners Grant and Natalya Sharp are all about good natural food and customers can taste that goodness in every bite.  

Located at Milepost 13 in Nags Head, across from Jockey’s Ridge State Park, we have unbelievable views from our second floor deck of the Atlantic Ocean and the historic Nags Head cottages. As a matter of fact, we don’t believe that you can truly unwind until you’ve ordered an Orange Crush on the deck at Mulligan’s!If you take one look at our menu you will find that we strive to bring the freshest possible products to your table—from locally sourced produce, locally sourced seafood and locally baked breads. From house-made sauces, hand-patted burgers and oysters and shrimp straight from the Pamlico sound, we give a whole new meaning to Southern Coastal Cuisine. So come hang out with the locals at Mulligan’s Raw Bar & Grille!!!Our hours of operation are 11am – 10 pm Monday through FridayAnd                                             10 am -10pm Saturday and Sunday for our Brunch MenuOpen Year Round!!

Pizza fans of all tastes will find something to love at Nags Head Pizza Company, thanks to its lengthy menu that’s filled with both traditional and more unique and creative pies for hungry patrons who want to try something new. Able to accommodate special diets, with gluten free and even vegan options, Nags Head Pizza Company is a great option for a pizza feast that the whole family can dig into.

The Outer Banks Brewing Station, established in 2001, is the first wind powered brewpub in the U.S. and an icon on the Outer Banks of North Carolina. Look for the 92 foot wind turbine in the backyard beer garden. A pub by the classic European style of a ‘public house’, the Brewing Station considers itself an important member of the community and is family friendly during lunch and dinner hours. Families can enjoy live music, beer and food inside and out, while the little ones play on the pirate ship and the older ones play a friendly game of corn hole. It’s also a great place to wait for your table during the busy summer season.

Papa John’s Pizza serves fresh, delicious pizza made just the way you like it. Piled with toppings and loaded with cheese, Papa John’s is a familar favorite for pizza delivery and takeout no matter where you live. 

Pizza is a must have meal when on vacation and sometimes you just have to go with a reliable favorite. Everyone knows and loves Pizza Hut pizza. Whether you decide to dine in or order delivery or carry out, Pizza Hut will satisfy your craving for cheesy pizza with all your favorite toppings piled on high.

Enjoy New York style pizza here on the Outer Banks! Hand-tossed pizza, hoagies, homemade sauce cooked in stone deck ovens. Pizza Stop sets itself apart from other pizza joints on the Outer Banks by offering delivery of cold beer!Appetizers on the menu include wings, mozzarella sticks, cheese bread, garlic bread and garlic knots. Pick your favorite toppings from pepperoni, sausage, ham, bacon, pineapple, black olives, banana peppers, meatballs, anchovies, feta cheese, jalapenos, roasted red peppers and spinach. If you can’t decide on individual toppings order a specialty pizza - supreme, veggie, meathead, margherita, BBQ chicken and classic white are the options. Pizzas are available in 12” and 17”. Supreme pizza is smothered in sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, green peppers and 5 additional toppings of your choice. Classic White specialty pizza is covered with ricotta, tomato slices, spinach mozzarella and fresh garlic. The Pizza Stop Meathead specialty pizza is unmatched with pepperoni, sausage, bacon and ham.  Hoagies grace the menu with taste bud tempting flavors as cheese steak, ham and cheese, eggplant parm, meatball, sausage and peppers, turkey and provolone or Italian cold cut. Pasta options and desserts are also available. Pizza Stop offers free delivery to Duck, Southern Shores, Martins Point, Kitty Hawk and Kill Devil Hills (to 3rd Street).

Pizzazz Pizza now has FOUR convenient Outer Banks locations in Grandy, Corolla, Duck & Nags Head. Made with only the freshest ingredients and finest meat toppings! Dine in, carry out or delivery (from Corolla to South Nags Head; from Powell's Point to Aydlett).

Sal's Pizza sells New York style pizza by the slice, whole pizza pies, hot Italian subs and hearty pasta dishes. 

Browse from store to store under covered porches and a grove of shady live oaks! Along the meandering Duck Road that runs through the village of Duck, NC, you’ll find the Scarborough Lane Shoppes, a collection of cool clothing boutiques and restaurants, shops that help you make your house a home, fun food stores, a place to relax, to taste and buy wine and craft beer, art to express your taste in living and jewelry to express yourself.Outer Banks shopping aficionados know that Scarborough Lane Shoppes puts them in Duck NC Shopping Central where they can find…well, practically anything they want. Browsing from store to store is comfortable under the covered porches that connect the shops, no matter what the weather. So, when the sun’s too hot or the rain is pouring (the best Outer Banks shopping days, by the way!), Scarborough Lane is the place. And, when it’s time to take a pause, or if you’re simply starving, two of Duck NC’s most-liked restaurants are right here.   Also on this site is our Specials sections where Outer Banks shopping experts know they can get valuable coupons and learn about the offers from each of our stores. If you’re not familiar with the area, you can go to our Directions tab to see a map and get oriented to the lay of the land for Duck, NC.

Sometimes you want a whole pizza, sometimes you just want a slice. Thankfully with Slice Pizzeria, you’ve got plenty of options. This popular dine in and take out restaurant serves up some of the tastiest pizzas you can experience on the beach, all made with fresh ingredients so that you can taste the quality.

Indulge in a craving for heaping plates of pastas and big and bold pizzas with a visit to this Ocracoke eatery that has plenty of global flavors and influences that are miles away from your typical Italian fare.  Sorellas Pizza & Pasta is a great spot to satisfy a large appetite, thanks to a wide selection of fresh pastas, pizzas, salads, and other treats that will leave patrons of all tastes smiling.

Tavern on 12 in Frisco is a fun and friendly restaurant with lots of homemade fare that is sure to please everyone in the crowd. From fresh seafood specials to hand-tossed pizzas with a range of specialty toppings, Tavern on 12 is a great destination for a little homegrown flavor on Hatteras Island.

The owners and staff of The Paper Canoe work hard to “make your vacation taste better.” This charming restaurant near Sanderling is best known for its stunning waterfront setting, its always evolving menu and its fresh ingredients, including local-caught seafood and home-grown vegetables from the chef’s own backyard. This dedication to its dishes, “prepared simply and with passion,” is coupled with PC’s commitment to your dining experience, “from the time you walk in the door.” Featured are their handmade pastas, wood-fired pizzas and other rustic wood oven specialties along with “an ever-changing chalkboard of daily selections.”

Tomato Patch Pizzeria and Bar Welcome! We’re a family style restaurant that welcomes visitors to the Outer Banks with a friendly staff, great food and a warm atmosphere. Family owned and operated since 1993, we offer Greek style pizza, pastas, subs, wraps, salads and seafood. Try one of our specialties, like Zorba the Greek Pizza, Gyros, Greek Salad or our Corolla Seafood Pasta. Don’t miss our new Buffalo Chicken Wrap, Gluten Free Pizza and Pasta, or Linda’s delicious Crabcakes. Lasagna, meatballs, and pizzas are all homemade daily and delicious. Our bar is always casual and offers great drink specials and lots of wine and beer and large screen TVs to view your favorite game. With over 120 seats available, large parties are no problem. Can’t dine in? We always welcome Carry Out. In fact, if you’re ordering “To go”, order 5 large pizzas and receive 1 large free cheese. (Take out only, one coupon per order) Come on in and see us.  We'd love to have you!

A specialty gourmet market and wine shop with plenty of surprises!

Established in 1976 in Nags Head, Yellow Submarine was the first eatery on the Outer Banks to offer oven-baked subs. Since then, the menu has expanded considerably to include hand-tossed pizza with fresh sauce and Philly or chicken cheesesteaks. Pizzas range from veggie to classic white, Greek, Buffalo chicken, Meat Monster and Hawaiian White. Various flavored of wings offered. Deli subs made with fresh Boars Head meats & cheeses. Located at Outer Banks Mall at Milepost 14 off the Bypass, this comfortable restaurant also offers Caesar, Greek, Buffalo Chicken and Chef salads, numerous snacks and draft beer. Want something sweet? Have some N.Y. style cheesecake. Kids menu, for dine-in only, includes chicken tenders and pizza. Delivery is available between Mileposts 10 and 21 with a minimum order of $15.